huddlesOpen Huddles
A person in a dark bedroom wearing a headset, face turned away, lit by a blurred fantasy landscape on a monitor, a plain white mask lying on the desk beside the keyboard.
Essay

Person or persona

Two in five players told their game friends things they would not tell anyone at home, and most still trusted the people at home more. On anonymity, intimacy, and whether we are meeting people or personas.

There is a kind of friendship a lot of people have and rarely describe. It lives in a headset. You have spent hundreds of hours with this person. You know how they sound when they are tired, what their dog is called, and the thing about their brother they have never told anyone else. You do not know their surname. You may not know what they look like.

Is that a friend? Ask someone who has one and they will say yes without hesitating. Ask a slightly different question — would you give them a key to your house? — and the hesitation arrives.

What 912 players said

In 2007 Helena Cole and Mark Griffiths of Nottingham Trent University surveyed 912 players of online role-playing games, from forty-five countries and about half of them in World of Warcraft, about the people they played with. It is not a flashy paper. It is a questionnaire, posted on gaming forums and answered by people who chose to answer it, so it describes the enthusiastic end of the hobby rather than all of it. But the numbers have aged remarkably well, and they say something that matters more now than it did then.

  • About three in four had made good friends inside the game, seven of them on average.
  • Two in five said they discussed sensitive things with game friends that they would not discuss with their friends in real life: family problems, losing someone, sexuality, discrimination, work.
  • A third said they could be more themselves in the game than out of it. Asked why, they said they were not judged on how they looked, their gender or their age.
  • Two in five had met game friends offline. Nearly a third had been attracted to another player, and one in ten had gone on to a physical relationship with one.

To explain the sensitive conversations, the authors borrow from the psychologist John Suler, who named two of the things that make people say more online: you don't know me, and you can't see me. Anonymity and invisibility. Take away the name and the face, and the consequences that follow them, and people talk.

The number that does not fit

Here is the one that stopped us. Asked whom they trusted more, just over half said their real-life friends. Fewer than one in twenty said their friends from the game.

Put that beside the two in five who told game friends what they would not tell real ones. A lot of people were taking their deepest things to the people they trusted less.

It stops looking like a contradiction once you see it. The secret goes to the game friend because they are far away. They cannot tell your mother. They do not know your manager. They will never sit across a dinner table from you and remember. That safety is real, but it is the safety of distance rather than the safety of trust, and the two are not the same thing even when, at one in the morning, they feel identical.

Anonymity is not the problem

It would be easy to turn this into a sermon about anonymity. We want to be careful not to, because the paper does not support one and neither do we.

Anonymity does real good. The third of players who felt more themselves in the game were not lying in it. They were, for once, not being read through a body they had not chosen. A teenager working out who they are, someone grieving who cannot say so at home, someone whose accent or age or face gets them talked over: for those people a space without names is not a mask. It is a way in.

The less flashy truth is about what anonymity gets used for.

Anonymity is leverage. It lets you say a thing without the thing being attached to you, and used well, that is exactly what finally lets somebody say the true sentence. But leverage works in every direction, and the easiest thing to do with it is to keep everything unattached: the words, the promises, the history, the person. Nothing you say is yours, so nothing you say costs you anything. Which also means nothing you say can quite be relied on.

That leaves the person on the other end with a question they cannot answer from inside the game. Is this a person, or a persona?

Two meanings of one word

In The closed door we wrote about a Cornell experiment on attribution in the listener's sense: why did she tell me that? Reading the same disclosure in a chat window, people answered generously, it was for me, and felt closer for it.

There is a second sense of the word, and it is the one anonymity takes away. Attribution is also the speaker's name on the words. I said this. You can hold me to it.

Put the two together and you get the odd shape of a lot of online intimacy. The listener attributes everything to the relationship. The speaker attributes nothing to themselves. One of you is investing in a friendship; the other may be investing in a character. Very often both are sincere and it works out — two in five of these players went and met each other. But nothing about the space tells you which situation you are in.

The persona is not always a lie

To be fair to the persona: it is not always a mask over a real face. For the players who felt more themselves in the game, the character may have been nearer the truth than the person their coworkers know. Is this person real? sometimes has an uncomfortable answer: more real here than anywhere else.

So the useful question is not whether somebody is anonymous. It is whether, when it starts to matter, there is a way for the persona to become answerable to a person. Whether the friendship has somewhere to go.

What a room can do

We build a place where people talk, so we have had to decide where we stand. What we have ended up with is a gradient rather than a switch.

A name is a visit. You can walk into a huddle you were invited to with nothing but a name and a face you picked. No account, no email address. The lightest possible way in is how a stranger becomes a guest, and we would not want to lose it.

An account is a place. Some things need a person behind them, and friendship is the clearest case. A friend in Huddles is requested by one of you and accepted by the other, and both ends need a verified account. Not because visitors are suspect, but because a friendship points at a person, and a name typed into a door is not one yet.

Known, not exposed. The address that makes somebody a verified person is never shown to the room. Other people see the name you chose and the face you chose, and even a generated avatar is drawn from an identifier of ours, never from your email. Answerable underneath, your own choice on the surface: it is the nearest we have found to keeping what anonymity is good for while giving a friendship something solid to stand on.

Safety never needs an account. Anyone in a conversation can report someone in it, signed in or not.

And it is mostly voice. A voice proves nothing. But you can hear somebody hesitate, laugh and get tired, and most of the cues that tell you there is a person there live in the voice, which is the thing Huddles carries.

None of this settles the question for you. You will still meet people whose name is the only thing you know about them, and some of them will be personas. What a room can do is not require that, and make sure there is always a next step from a name to a person, taken by both of you, on purpose.

Where that leaves us

The players in that survey were not naive. They knew whom they trusted. They told their secrets to the people who could not hurt them and kept their house keys for the people who could. That is a sensible strategy in a world where the only private places online are the anonymous ones.

We would like there to be another kind of place: one where you can be known, a little or a lot, by your own choice, and where the people you tell your real things to can be real to you too.

Was this useful?
More from the room
What is Huddles?6 min The closed door7 min Notes that write themselves6 min
huddles

A space to connect with anyone, anywhere — one link and they are in.